ReviewShield Analysis
AI compliance scan · 5-channel appeal pack ready to send
Review under analysis · ASIN B0••••••••• · 1-star
★☆☆☆☆
"Stopped working after 2 weeks — and the brand wouldn't help"
"I bought this for my home gym and it stopped working after 2 weeks. I emailed the brand asking for a refund and they offered me a $30 gift card if I changed my review to 5 stars. When I refused, they stopped responding. Don't trust this seller — they bribe customers. Also my friend ordered the same brand on AliExpress for half the price, so this is just a markup."
Policy Violations Detected (3)
Defamation / False Accusation
High Severity
"Don't trust this seller — they bribe customers"
Policy: Customer Reviews · "Reviews must not contain personal information or claims that could be defamatory"
Reviewer makes an unverifiable accusation of bribery as fact. Amazon explicitly bans defamatory claims about sellers. The reviewer presents it as conclusion, not opinion ("they bribe customers" — not "I felt bribed"). This is the strongest of the 3 violations.
Compensated Review / Solicitation Claim
High Severity
"...offered me a $30 gift card if I changed my review to 5 stars"
Policy: Customer Product Reviews · Sec. 4.2 "Compensation in exchange for reviews"
Allegation of review manipulation. If true, this violates Amazon's compensation policy (the reviewer should report through proper channels, not within a review). If false, it's a defamatory accusation. Either way, the review itself is non-compliant content.
Off-Topic / Irrelevant Content
Medium Severity
"my friend ordered the same brand on AliExpress for half the price"
Policy: Reviews must focus on the product and your experience with it
Pricing comparisons with off-platform retailers are explicitly off-topic per Amazon's review guidelines. Reviewer is using the review for unrelated commentary.
5-Channel Appeal Pack — Ready to Send
1
Brand Registry — Report Abuse
71% success rate · highest priority
brandregistry → "Report a Violation"
Subject: Defamatory review with unverified bribery claims — ASIN B0••••••••• — Review ID R••••••
Hello Brand Registry team,
We are reporting customer review R••••••• on our ASIN B0••••••••• for violation of Amazon's Customer Reviews Policy. The review contains:
1. A defamatory accusation that we "bribe customers" — presented as fact, with no supporting evidence
2. A specific unverifiable claim that we offered "$30 gift card if I changed my review to 5 stars" — we have no record of this contact and our brand has never solicited reviews
3. Off-topic content comparing our product to "AliExpress" pricing, unrelated to product experience
We respectfully request review takedown under sections 4.2 and 4.7 of the Customer Product Reviews Policy. Brand: ████████ · ABN: ██████ · Brand Registry ID: ██████.
Thank you,
[Your Name]
Brand Owner, ████████
2
Community Help — Report Abuse Form
48-72h SLA
community-help@amazon.com
Subject: Customer review violates content guidelines — ASIN B0•••••••••
Hello Community Help team,
I am writing to report customer review R••••••• on ASIN B0••••••••• that violates Amazon's Customer Reviews Policy on multiple counts: defamatory accusations stated as fact, unverifiable bribery claim, and off-topic AliExpress pricing comparison.
The review's defamatory content damages the seller reputation. We have already filed the same case via Brand Registry. Please process this report through Community Help channels in parallel.
Original review excerpt: "Don't trust this seller — they bribe customers"
Thank you for your prompt attention.
3
Account Health — Performance Notification
Use if violation affects metrics
Seller Central → Performance → Account Health → Contact us
Subject: Defamatory customer review impacting account health — ASIN B0•••••••••
To Account Health team,
Review R••••••• on ASIN B0••••••••• contains content that violates Customer Reviews Policy and is contributing to incorrect customer perception of our brand. Three policy issues are present (defamation, unverifiable bribery accusation, off-topic content).
Requesting review removal in line with Customer Reviews Policy sections 4.2 and 4.7. Full case detail and reviewer-specific quotes available on request.
[Seller Account ID: ██████]
4
Executive Escalation
Use only after 1-3 fail · 5-7 day wait
jeff@amazon.com (auto-routed to Exec Customer Relations)
Subject: Review violation case unresolved after 3 channels — ASIN B0•••••••••
Hi Executive team,
After filing through Brand Registry, Community Help, and Account Health, the defamatory customer review R••••••• on ASIN B0••••••••• remains live. The review contains three distinct policy violations and is causing measurable conversion damage (-12% CVR week-over-week since posting).
Case references: BR••••••, CH••••••, AH••••••.
Requesting human review of this case through Executive Customer Relations.
Brand: ████████ · 9 years on Amazon · 4.6★ overall.
5
"Report Abuse" — Direct Review Link
Always file in parallel
Click "Report" under the review on the product page
Reason to select: "Inappropriate / Off-topic content"
Sub-reason: "Contains unverifiable accusations or defamatory statements"
Optional comment box (paste this):
"Review contains defamatory bribery accusation stated as fact, unverifiable compensated-review claim, and off-topic AliExpress pricing comparison. All three violate Customer Reviews Policy. Filed via Brand Registry case BR•••••• in parallel."
Want appeals like this for your reviews?
This is what ReviewShield generates for every review you upload — verdict, violations, and 5 ready-to-send emails. First analysis is free.